The First Game

The first game ever was played five years prior to the season one games. These games were unknown until William Holt mentioned them to Danny Ferguson in The forbidden ally.

Known games
Only one game has been revealed, and that game looks a lot like Pizza Party, from season two, except for the fact that they all got a gun at the start, and were tasked with killing the host, except they were all dressed in the same clothes, and if they were to undress themselves, and make themselves known, they would be executed. This resulted in Aria Thorne's death, as she had a similar build to the host.

The Host
The host of the first game ever is unknown

Winners

 * Ritt Hayward
 * William Holt
 * Danny Ferguson
 * Alyssa Thorne
 * Marin Everett

Losers

 * Aria Thorne

Notes and trivia

 * These games mirror those of season one. Each of the players from the season one games represent someone from the first game ever.
 * Joana Clarkeson (William Holt)
 * Alexander Morris (Alyssa Thorne)
 * Chris Maddox (Danny Ferguson)
 * Keely Stark (Marin Everett)
 * Kirsten Forest (Ritt Hayward)
 * Nicole Hoover (Aria Thorne)

During the final game, each of the players had to play the same game/complete the same task as their counterpart.